Reading
Read the article, then choose the best answer to each question.
The headline we nearly published
On Monday evening, our school media club received a twelve-second video of a crowded corridor. The caption claimed that students had walked out because the library was closing permanently. As the club’s new editor, I could already imagine the headline. We had been trying to attract more readers, and this was exactly the kind of story that would get attention.
Most of the team wanted to post immediately. The clip had been shared hundreds of times, and several familiar accounts had repeated the claim. Zara, our photographer, was less convinced. She asked who had filmed it and whether anyone had spoken to the librarian. I thought she was being unnecessarily cautious. Surely, I argued, so many people couldn’t all be mistaken.
Finding the original upload took longer than expected. The accounts we recognised had simply copied one another. Eventually, a former student replied to our message. He said that he had recorded the video two years earlier, during a practice evacuation. Someone had added a new caption that afternoon. The librarian then confirmed that a study room would close for repairs for three days; the library itself would remain open.
There was still a genuine issue worth reporting. Students needed to know where they could study during the repairs, especially those preparing for exams. We interviewed the librarian and published a practical update with the correct dates and alternative spaces. It received fewer views than a dramatic accusation probably would have, but several students thanked us for making their week easier.
The most uncomfortable part was admitting how close I had come to publishing the original claim. I had treated popularity as evidence and speed as an achievement. Zara suggested adding a simple check to our routine: before a surprising story went live, someone who had not written it should question the source and the context. We also agreed to label any uncertainty instead of hiding it behind a confident headline.
This does not mean that student journalists should avoid difficult stories or trust every official statement automatically. It means asking fair questions and checking answers against independent evidence. We cannot guarantee that we will never make a mistake. However, we can explain what we know, acknowledge what we do not know, and correct errors openly. That seems a better way to earn readers’ trust than winning their attention for a few seconds.
Reading questions
